1

The promoted benefits of how using XLM to send money around the world is that it is instantaneous and nearly free in comparison to traditional banks. That is, it's promoted as a "fast and cheap alternative" to traditional banking.

I was sold on the idea, but for practical purposes, what good is it? XLM can't be used to buy groceries or pay rent, and I don't see this happening anytime in the near future or even the next two decades. Maybe, but you can't do it now or soon which is what I need.

I am not opposed to XLM, quite the opposite. Below is what I am trying to learn and understand, not a criticism of XLM. So please keep this in mind. I am genuinely trying to understand how to use XLM in the real world to solve real-world problems.

Basically here is the scenario.

  • I have USD.
  • I want to make my USD into Euro to use overseas.
  • If I use a traditional bank, there are fees.**
  • XLM as an alternative to avoid fees?***

** When using a bank, I do not get the middle-market rate (the "real" exchange rate), I get the hidden fee rate (bank gives you a lower rate than the real exchange rate).

*** I want to use USD or EUR in another country and leverage the power of XLM to do what it promises - fast and virtually free transfer of money that I can use practically - NOT just in theory or if I found some obscure vendor who accepted XLM directly, because we are not there yet and not anytime soon. I mean so that I can use my USD cash in my pocket and pay in EUR for food and shelter, that is, basic human needs. This is the purpose of money after all. And I want to do it while not having middlemen take another "cut" of the fruits of my hard labor (they already stole some of my money in "taxes") just because I want to buy something in a different location.

While I am still learning about what options are available so I can use my money without a middleman (bank, exchange, etc) taking some of it for the privilege of using MY money that I worked hard for, it occurred to me that since XLM is supposed to solve the problems with traditional banks, this should in theory be a way to send your money around the world fast and virtually free ("virtually" free compared to traditional methods. The fee is so small it is not impactful).

The problem when I am faced with a real-world situation is I don't know how to leverage the benefits that XLM offers in the real world without incurring the same or even potentially higher fees than even the best traditional bank would charge. In which case, what would be the point of XLM?

Even if you weren't doing a currency conversion, and instead just wanted to send USD to USD in a different place, the problem still occurs that you need to convert USD > ETH > XLM incurring quite a bit of fees, and then AGAIN convert XLM > ETH > USD.

And even if exchanges accepted an XLM/USD pair, so that the procedure would be USD > XLM > [TRANSFER] > XLM > USD, then again there are TWO points, an entry and exit in which it is exchanged from USD to XLM incurring fees, and then XLM to USD incurring fees so that you or someone can use it at the destination.

So my question becomes, how can we use XLM in the real world, or is it simply a defunct, useless currency for practical purposes until the day comes (if ever) that it is accepted as real currency by vendors, rentals, banks, stores, etc?

Please tell me if there is a way to use XLM for practical purposes, because I'm starting to believe that the entire crypto industry is effectively an elaborate scam to enrich exchanges and middlemen at rates even higher than traditional banks. If this is wrong and there is a way, please explain. I believe in the idea of XLM but if there is no way to actually use it until it is accepted as a nation's official currency and by vendors etc then there is no practical reason to actually use it.

How can you use XLM as a way to use your money with the promises of a "fast and cheap" (virtually free is the promoted thing) way to transfer money? And how can you do it to transfer money from one currency to another for far cheaper (virtually free) than traditional methods, to avoid "exchange" fees?

1 Answer 1

1

Thanks to stellar you can compare various services. I think that what you are looking for are remittance services.

You can find some information here: https://www.stellar.org/learn/stellar-for-remittances

For example, Tempo Money Transfer offers to transfer 100 EUR to a SEPA account for 2.41 EUR from a stellar account where 994.2996799 XLM will be taken from (including fees).

The same transfer from stellar to EUR cash cost 0.4 EUR, so a total of 991.573607 XLM if Tempo has a local agency

2
  • That's really expensive. I know of other transfer services that don't use crypto that will not take 2-5% fees to transfer back and forth. Traditional money transfer services can be under a half a percent for the best services to convert for example from USD to Euro. To have an incentive to use crypto it would need to be LOWER than the lowest. The purpose of XLM is to be fast and virtually free. I expect out of $10,000 transfer and currency conversion to be under 1 CENT. At your rate, it would cost $241.00 to convert from USD to XLM, and then more to transfer XLM to EUR!!
    – user7211
    Jul 12, 2022 at 4:12
  • Meanwhile the best I found with no fees and a competitive exchange rate would be $10,000 USD at an exchange rate over the mid-market rate of only 0.34% (1/3 of a percent), in other words the transfer fee ends up being only $34 TOTAL for a $10,000 transfer and conversion, whereas your recommendation will cost 10 TIMES MORE at nearly $300!! In other words, your solution is 10 TIMES WORSE than using traditional money transfer services WITHOUT Stellar Lumens. So, my question remains.
    – user7211
    Jul 12, 2022 at 4:17

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.